Theory: Mass Defect, Binding Energy, and Q-Values
Why Binding Energy Matters
Every nuclear technology, from reactors to medical isotopes to fusion research, depends on one fact: a nucleus weighs less than the protons and neutrons it is made of. The missing mass has become the binding energy that holds the nucleus together, through Einstein's E = mc². The way binding energy per nucleon changes across the elements explains why splitting heavy nuclei (fission) and joining light ones (fusion) both release energy, and it lets an analyst work out exactly how much energy any decay or reaction releases from a table of masses.
Mass Defect and Binding Energy
Atomic masses are measured very precisely with mass spectrometers and tabulated in unified atomic mass units (u). The mass defect Δm is the difference between the mass of the separate nucleons and the mass of the atom. Using the mass of the hydrogen atom for each proton means the electron masses cancel. One atomic mass unit is equivalent to 931.494 MeV.
BE = Δm × 931.494 MeV/u BE/A = binding energy per nucleon
The Binding Energy Curve
BE/A rises steeply through the light nuclei, peaks at about 8.8 MeV per nucleon near iron and nickel (Ni-62 is the most tightly bound, just ahead of Fe-56), and then falls slowly to about 7.6 MeV for uranium. Moving towards the peak releases energy. Splitting U-235 into two mid-mass fragments raises BE/A by almost 1 MeV per nucleon, which is about 200 MeV per fission. Fusing hydrogen isotopes into helium raises BE/A even more per nucleon. Alpha particles (He-4) are unusually tightly bound for their size, which is why heavy nuclei emit them.
Q-Values of Decays and Reactions
The Q-value is the energy released by a decay or reaction. It equals the mass lost, converted to energy. A positive Q means the process can happen spontaneously or releases energy. When a nucleus at rest splits into two products, they fly apart with equal and opposite momentum, so the lighter product carries most of the kinetic energy. This is why alpha particles from a given nuclide have a single, sharp energy, while beta particles, which share their energy with an antineutrino, have a continuous spectrum.
Two products from rest: KE_light = Q × A_heavy / (A_light + A_heavy)
α decay: KE_α = Q (A − 4)/A
Data Used in This Lab
| Nuclide | Atomic mass (u) | Nuclide | Atomic mass (u) |
|---|---|---|---|
| n | 1.008665 | H-1 | 1.007825 |
| H-2 | 2.014102 | H-3 | 3.016049 |
| He-4 | 4.002602 | Co-60 / Ni-60 | 59.933817 / 59.930786 |
| Kr-92 | 91.926173 | Ba-141 | 140.914403 |
| Pb-206 / Po-210 | 205.974465 / 209.982874 | Rn-222 / Ra-226 | 222.017578 / 226.025410 |
| Th-234 | 234.043601 | U-235 / U-238 | 235.043928 / 238.050787 |
Atomic masses from the Atomic Mass Evaluation (AME), rounded to six decimal places, as used in the DOE Fundamentals Handbook (Nuclear Physics and Reactor Theory, Module 1). The fission shown is one of many possible splits; the prompt Q-value here (about 173 MeV) excludes the energy released later by fission-product decay, which brings the total recoverable energy to about 200 MeV per fission.
Power
One kilogram of U-235 fully fissioned releases about as much energy as 2 to 3 million kilograms of coal.
Fusion
D–T fusion gives 14.1 MeV neutrons, which set the shielding and materials problems of fusion reactors.
Spectroscopy
Sharp alpha energies (Po-210: 5.30 MeV) identify nuclides in alpha spectrometry of environmental samples.
Using the Curve, the Semi-Empirical Formula, and Thresholds
Because Q equals the gain in total binding energy, the BE/A curve gives quick energy estimates: moving 235 nucleons from 7.6 MeV to about 8.5 MeV releases roughly 200 MeV. The semi-empirical (liquid-drop) mass formula explains the curve with five terms: a volume term proportional to A, a surface term, the Coulomb repulsion of the protons, an asymmetry term that favours N ≈ Z, and a pairing term. For an endothermic reaction (Q < 0) the projectile must bring more than |Q|, because momentum must be conserved: the threshold is E_th = −Q(1 + m_a/m_A). A charged projectile must also approach the target against the Coulomb barrier, E_C ≈ 1.44 Z₁Z₂/R MeV with R in femtometres; neutrons feel no barrier.
Apparatus
The instruments and references behind mass and energy measurements. In the simulation these are modelled for you, and the readings correspond to what each would report.
Instructions: Running the Virtual Experiment
You are preparing an energy analysis for a briefing on fission and fusion. The simulation has two immersive 3D work areas and two graph work areas. The parts build from undergraduate work in Parts A and B to graduate-level analysis in the last step of Parts C and D; the level of each part is shown beside its title. In each one you take measurements, work out the answer yourself, enter it, and press Check. Record every reading and calculation in your lab report tables (modelled in the Example Report), with a labelled screenshot of each setup. Drag in any 3D view to orbit, and scroll to zoom. Keep six decimal places in every mass.
Simulation: Mass Spectrometer, Reaction Bench, and Energy Graphs
Choose a nuclide and measure its atomic mass. Using atomic masses (which include the electrons) with the mass of the hydrogen atom for each proton keeps the electron masses balanced. Part A uses this work area.
Setup
Readings
Masses are from the Atomic Mass Evaluation, in unified atomic mass units (u).
Work it out, then check
| Nuclide | Z | N | M (u) | Δm (u) | BE (MeV) | BE/A (MeV) |
|---|
Choose a decay or reaction and run it. The Q-value is the energy released, equal to the mass lost times c². Part B uses this work area.
Setup
Readings
For two products from reactants at rest, momentum is shared equally, so the lighter product takes the larger share of the energy: KE_light ≈ Q × A_heavy / (A_light + A_heavy).
Work it out, then check
| Reaction | Δm (u) | Q (MeV) | KE of light product (MeV) | Energy per kg of fuel (J/kg) |
|---|
The binding-energy curve is the reason nuclear energy exists: moving nucleons from either end of the curve toward the peak releases energy. Part C uses this work area.
Setup
Readings
Curve estimates use BE/A read from the graph; the semi-empirical formula is BE = a_V A − a_S A^(2/3) − a_C Z(Z−1)/A^(1/3) − a_A (A − 2Z)²/A + δ.
Work it out, then check
| Nuclide | A | BE/A measured (MeV) | BE/A semi-empirical (MeV) | Difference (%) |
|---|
A reaction can release energy (Q > 0) or need it (Q < 0). Charged projectiles must also be pushed close enough against the Coulomb barrier. Part D uses this work area.
Setup
Readings
Q = 931.494 [Σm_in − Σm_out] MeV. Coulomb barrier E_C ≈ 1.44 Z₁Z₂ / [1.2(A₁^(1/3) + A₂^(1/3))] MeV.
Work it out, then check
| Reaction | Q (MeV) | Exo or endo | Coulomb barrier (MeV) | Threshold (MeV) |
|---|
This accessible version provides the same set-up, work-out, and check exercises as the 3D and graph work areas, using native controls, data tables, and screen-reader announcements.
Team Questions
Example Lab Report
Sample report showing the expected format and level of detail. Use it as a guide for your own submission, and include labelled screenshots of each setup.
Mass Defect, Binding Energy, and Reaction Q-Values
Nuclear Physics | Section: [Your Section] | Date: [Date]
Lab Members: [Names of all members present]
Purpose
To calculate the mass defect, binding energy, and binding energy per nucleon of nuclides across the periodic table from measured atomic masses; and to calculate the Q-values, particle energies, and energy per kilogram of fuel for alpha decay, beta decay, fusion, and fission; to estimate fission and fusion energy from the binding-energy curve and test the semi-empirical mass formula; and to find the Q-values, Coulomb barriers, and threshold energies of reactions used in neutron sources and detectors.
Theory
The mass defect is Δm = Z m_H + N m_n − M, and BE = 931.494 Δm MeV. The Q-value of a reaction is the mass lost times 931.494 MeV/u. For two products from rest, the lighter one carries Q × A_heavy/(A_light + A_heavy).
Table A: Binding Energy Undergraduate
| Nuclide | Z | N | M (u) | Δm (u) | BE (MeV) | BE/A (MeV) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| H-2 | 1 | 1 | 2.014102 | 0.002388 | 2.22 | 1.112 |
| He-4 | 2 | 2 | 4.002602 | 0.030378 | 28.30 | 7.074 |
| Li-7 | 3 | 4 | 7.016003 | 0.042132 | 39.25 | 5.607 |
| C-12 | 6 | 6 | 12.000000 | 0.098940 | 92.16 | 7.680 |
| O-16 | 8 | 8 | 15.994915 | 0.137005 | 127.62 | 7.976 |
| Fe-56 | 26 | 30 | 55.934936 | 0.528464 | 492.26 | 8.790 |
| Ni-62 | 28 | 34 | 61.928345 | 0.585365 | 545.26 | 8.795 |
| Sn-120 | 50 | 70 | 119.902202 | 1.095598 | 1020.54 | 8.505 |
| Pb-208 | 82 | 126 | 207.976652 | 1.756788 | 1636.44 | 7.867 |
| U-235 | 92 | 143 | 235.043928 | 1.915067 | 1783.87 | 7.591 |
| U-238 | 92 | 146 | 238.050787 | 1.934203 | 1801.70 | 7.570 |
Table B: Q-Values Undergraduate
| Reaction | Δm (u) | Q (MeV) | KE of light product (MeV) | Energy per kg of fuel (J/kg) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ra-226 → Rn-222 + α | 0.005230 | 4.872 | 4.785 (α) | — |
| U-238 → Th-234 + α | 0.004584 | 4.270 | 4.198 (α) | — |
| Po-210 → Pb-206 + α | 0.005807 | 5.409 | 5.306 (α) | — |
| Co-60 → Ni-60 + β⁻ + ν̄ | 0.003031 | 2.823 | 0 to 2.823 (shared) | — |
| D + T → He-4 + n | 0.018884 | 17.590 | 14.072 (n) | 3.374 × 10¹⁴ |
| n + U-235 → Ba-141 + Kr-92 + 3n | 0.186022 | 173.278 | — | 7.113 × 10¹³ |
Sample calculation (fission): Δm = (1.008665 + 235.043928) − (140.914403 + 91.926173 + 3.025995) = 0.186022 u; Q = 173.3 MeV; per kg of U-235: 173.3 × 1.602×10⁻¹³ × 6.022×10²³ / 0.235044 = 7.11×10¹³ J/kg.
Table C: Binding-Energy Curve and Semi-Empirical Formula Upper undergraduateGraduate step
| Nuclide | A | BE/A measured (MeV) | BE/A semi-empirical (MeV) | Difference (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| He-4 | 4 | 7.074 | 5.710 | −19.3 |
| C-12 | 12 | 7.680 | 7.468 | −2.8 |
| Fe-56 | 56 | 8.790 | 8.846 | +0.6 |
| Sn-120 | 120 | 8.505 | 8.548 | +0.5 |
| Pb-208 | 208 | 7.867 | 7.857 | −0.1 |
| U-235 | 235 | 7.591 | 7.645 | +0.7 |
Curve estimates: fission of U-235 ≈ 235 × (8.505 − 7.591) = 214.7 MeV; D–T fusion = 4(7.074) − 2(1.112) − 3(2.827) = 17.59 MeV, equal to the Table B mass result.
Graduate step: symmetric fission of U-236 into two Pd-118 from the semi-empirical formula: Q = 2(995.5) − 1803.2 = 187.7 MeV, compared with 214.7 MeV from the curve estimate and 173.3 MeV (prompt) for the Ba-141 + Kr-92 + 3n split in Table B.
Table D: Q-Values, Coulomb Barriers, and Thresholds Upper undergraduateGraduate step
| Reaction | Q (MeV) | Exo or endo | Coulomb barrier (MeV) | Threshold (MeV) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ¹⁴N(α,p)¹⁷O | −1.193 | Endo | 4.203 | 1.534 |
| ³H(p,n)³He | −0.764 | Endo | 0.491 | 1.019 |
| ⁷Li(p,n)⁷Be | −1.645 | Endo | 1.236 | 1.881 |
| ¹⁶O(n,p)¹⁶N | −9.638 | Endo | none (neutron) | 10.246 |
| ¹⁰B(n,α)⁷Li | 2.792 | Exo | none (neutron) | 0 |
| ⁶Li(n,α)³H | 4.785 | Exo | none (neutron) | 0 |
| ²H(d,n)³He | 3.270 | Exo | 0.476 | 0 |
E_C = 1.44 Z₁Z₂/[1.2(A₁^(1/3) + A₂^(1/3))] MeV. Graduate step: the threshold column uses E_th = −Q(1 + m_a/m_A), e.g. ¹⁴N(α,p): 1.193 × (1 + 4.002602/14.003074) = 1.534 MeV.
Discussion
Binding energy per nucleon rose from 1.1 MeV for deuterium to a peak of 8.79 MeV at Fe-56 and Ni-62 (Ni-62 slightly higher), then fell to 7.6 MeV for uranium. He-4, at 7.07 MeV, stood well above its neighbours Li-7 and H-2, showing why alpha particles are such stable packages and why heavy nuclei emit them. Splitting U-235 into two fragments near A = 90 to 140 moves each nucleon up the curve by almost 1 MeV, giving the 173 MeV prompt Q-value; fusing D and T into helium moves a few nucleons up by several MeV each.
The alpha emitters each gave a single alpha energy close to the full Q-value, because the heavy daughter recoils with only about 2% of it. Co-60 β⁻ decay has a fixed Q-value but no fixed electron energy, because the antineutrino takes a variable share. Per kilogram of fuel, D–T fusion released 3.4 × 10¹⁴ J/kg, almost five times as much as U-235 fission (7.1 × 10¹³ J/kg prompt), and both are millions of times more than burning coal (about 2.9 × 10⁷ J/kg). Most fusion energy, 14.07 MeV of 17.59, leaves as fast neutrons.
The graph work areas turned the curve into energy estimates. Reading BE/A from the curve gave about 215 MeV per fission, close to the textbook 200 MeV, and gave exactly the D–T Q-value, because Q is simply the gain in total binding energy. The semi-empirical formula matched the measured curve to within 1% from Fe-56 to U-235 but missed He-4 by 19%, because light nuclei are dominated by shell structure that the liquid-drop terms do not describe. The reaction chart showed why ¹⁰B(n,α) and ⁶Li(n,α) make good thermal-neutron detectors (positive Q, no barrier), while (p,n) reactions on lithium and tritium need accelerated protons.
The graduate steps added the physics a designer needs. The semi-empirical formula gave 188 MeV for symmetric fission: the Coulomb energy falls by much more than the surface energy rises, so splitting a heavy nucleus releases energy even though the liquid-drop surface grows. Threshold energies were 3% (¹⁶O(n,p)) to 33% (³H(p,n)) above |Q|, because momentum conservation leaves part of the projectile energy in motion of the centre of mass; the light projectile on a light target pays the largest penalty. The 10.2 MeV threshold of ¹⁶O(n,p)¹⁶N means only the fastest fission neutrons make N-16, but they do so in every water-cooled reactor, which is why the main steam lines of a BWR are shielded.
Conclusion
Measured atomic masses gave the binding energy curve, which explains why both fission and fusion release energy. Q-values from mass differences matched the known alpha energies, and nuclear fuels release millions of times more energy per kilogram than chemical fuels.
Practice Questions
Show all work and include units. Use the mass table in the Theory section.