Theory: Approach to Criticality and Reactor Kinetics
Why Startups Are Done Slowly
When a reactor is shut down, k is well below 1 and the power is too low for the power-range instruments to see. Operators bring it to critical by withdrawing control rods (or diluting boron) in small, deliberate steps while watching the source-range count rate. The plant procedure requires them to predict where criticality will occur, the estimated critical position (ECP), and to confirm it with a 1/M plot as they go. Once critical, they add a little positive reactivity and let power rise on a slow, controlled period, limited by a startup rate limit, typically 1 decade per minute (dpm).
Subcritical Multiplication
A subcritical core with a neutron source does not shut down to zero. Each source neutron starts a chain of 1 + k + k² + … neutrons, so the neutron population, and the detector count rate, settles at a level proportional to 1/(1 − k). The subcritical multiplication M compares the count rate now with the reference count rate CR₀ taken at the start. As k approaches 1, the count rate rises steeply and 1/M falls towards zero.
k₂ = 1 − (1 − k₁) CR₁ / CR₂
M = CR / CR₀ 1/M = CR₀ / CR = (1 − k)/(1 − k₀)
The 1/M Plot and the Estimated Critical Position
Plotting 1/M against rod position gives a curve that reaches zero at criticality. A straight line through the last two points, extended to 1/M = 0, predicts the critical position. Early extrapolations are poor, because rod worth is small near the bottom of the core and the curve is not straight. Each new pair of points brings the prediction closer to the true position, and procedures forbid withdrawing more than about half the remaining distance to the predicted ECP before counting again.
Integral and Differential Rod Worth
A control rod has its greatest effect where the flux is highest, in the middle of the core. Its differential worth (pcm per step) is small at the top and bottom and largest in the middle, so its integral worth follows an S-shaped curve. The bank in this lab is worth 6000 pcm in total and the reactor has k = 0.950 (ρ = −5263 pcm) with all rods inserted.
ρ(z) = −5263 + 6000 [ x − sin(2πx)/(2π) ] pcm, x = z/228
Prompt and Delayed Neutrons
About 99.35% of fission neutrons are emitted within 10⁻¹⁴ s (prompt). The other 0.65% (β ≈ 0.0065 for U-235) are emitted seconds to a minute later by fission products called delayed-neutron precursors. These few delayed neutrons make the reactor controllable: as long as the added reactivity is less than β, the chain cannot sustain itself on prompt neutrons alone, and power rises at a pace set by the precursor decay. If ρ reaches β, the reactor is prompt critical and power rises in a fraction of a second. Reactivity in reactor kinetics is often quoted in dollars: ρ($) = ρ/β.
Reactor Period, Startup Rate, and Doubling Time
A few seconds after a small step of positive reactivity, the power rises exponentially on a stable period τ, the time for power to increase by a factor of e. With one effective delayed-neutron group the period depends only on ρ. Control-room instruments display the startup rate in decades per minute, and operators often time the doubling time with a stopwatch. Measuring the period after a known rod withdrawal is a standard way to measure rod worth during startup physics testing.
P(t) = P₀ e^(t/τ) SUR = 26.06 / τ (dpm) T_d = τ ln 2
Data Used in This Lab
| Quantity | Value | Quantity | Value |
|---|---|---|---|
| k with all rods in | 0.950 (−5263 pcm) | Total bank worth | 6000 pcm over 228 steps |
| Effective delayed-neutron fraction β | 0.0065 (650 pcm) | Effective decay constant λ | 0.08 s⁻¹ |
| Source-range count time | 60 s | Startup rate limit (typical) | 1 dpm |
| Point of adding heat | about 1% rated power | Prompt neutron lifetime ℓ* | about 10⁻⁴ s (ignored) |
Values follow the DOE Fundamentals Handbook (Nuclear Physics and Reactor Theory, Module 4: Reactor Theory, Reactor Operations) and the NRC Reactor Concepts Manual. One effective delayed group with λ = 0.08 s⁻¹ is the DOE approximation for small positive reactivity; a real kinetics analysis uses six delayed groups.
Operators
Licensed operators perform the 1/M plot and ECP calculation at every startup, and stop if criticality comes earlier than predicted.
Reactor engineers
Startup physics tests measure rod worth and boron worth with a reactivity computer that applies the same period equations.
Safety limits
Startup-rate trips and limits keep the period long, so that delayed neutrons, not prompt ones, control the power rise.
Reading 1/M and Period Graphs in the Control Room
Operators plot 1/M from at least two source-range detectors. A detector close to the neutron source counts many source neutrons that have not multiplied, so its 1/M falls slowly at first and its extrapolation lands beyond the true critical position, which is not conservative. A detector farther away gives an earlier, safer estimate. The period curve, τ = (β − ρ)/(λρ), shows that the period shortens slowly at small reactivity and then collapses as ρ approaches β (one dollar, prompt criticality). A startup-rate limit is a limit on the shortest period, and therefore on the largest reactivity that may be added.
Apparatus
The plant equipment used during a reactor startup. In the simulation these are modelled for you, and the readings correspond to what each instrument would show in the control room.
Instructions: Running the Virtual Experiment
You are the reactor operator trainee at the controls for a PWR startup. The simulation has two immersive 3D work areas and two graph work areas. The parts build from undergraduate work in Parts A to C to graduate-level analysis in the last step of Parts D and E; the level of each part is shown beside its title. In each one you operate the plant, take readings, work out the answer yourself, enter it, and press Check. Record every reading and calculation in your lab report tables (modelled in the Example Report), with a labelled screenshot of each setup. Drag in any 3D view to orbit, and scroll to zoom.
Simulation: Approach to Criticality, Power Ascension, and Kinetics Graphs
The reactor is shut down with all rods in (k = 0.950, found from the shutdown margin calculation). A neutron source keeps the source-range detector counting. Withdraw the control bank in steps, count for 60 s at each position, and watch the count rate climb as k approaches 1. Part A uses this work area.
Setup
Count once at 0 steps first: that count is your reference count rate CR₀. Withdraw in smaller steps as the count rate climbs.
Readings
k at 0 steps is 0.950. The count rate is source-limited: CR = S_eff / (1 − k).
Work it out, then check
| Bank (steps) | Counts (60 s) | CR (cps) | 1/M | k | Extrapolated critical position (steps) |
|---|
The reactor is now just critical at a low power. Add positive reactivity, start the stopwatch, and watch the log-power recorder. Power rises on a stable period after a few seconds. Part B and Part C use this work area.
Setup
Readings
Delayed-neutron data (one effective group): β_eff = 0.0065 (650 pcm), λ_eff = 0.08 s⁻¹. The prompt term ℓ*/ρ is under 0.1 s and is ignored.
Work it out, then check
| Reactivity source | ρ (pcm) | τ (s) | SUR (dpm) | T_d (s) | Measured T_d (s) | Within 1 dpm limit? |
|---|
During a real startup the operators plot 1/M from more than one source-range detector. A detector close to the neutron source can give an estimate of the critical position that is too high, which is not conservative. Part D uses this work area.
Setup
Readings
1/M = CR₀/CR. Extrapolate the straight line through the two points to 1/M = 0. Logged training data.
Work it out, then check
| Detector | Positions (steps) | 1/M first | 1/M second | Extrapolated critical position | Actual critical position | Conservative? |
|---|
Every startup has a startup-rate limit, often 1 decade per minute. The period curve shows how sharply the period shortens as the added reactivity rises toward prompt criticality. Part E uses this work area.
Setup
Readings
τ = (β − ρ)/(λρ); SUR = 26.06/τ dpm; reactivity in dollars = ρ/β.
Work it out, then check
| ρ (pcm) | ρ ($) | τ (s) | SUR (dpm) | Limit (dpm) | Largest ρ allowed (pcm) | Within limit? |
|---|
This accessible version provides the same set-up, work-out, and check exercises as the 3D and graph work areas, using native controls, data tables, and screen-reader announcements.
Team Questions
Example Lab Report
Sample report showing the expected format and level of detail. Use it as a guide for your own submission, and include labelled screenshots of each setup. Your counts will differ slightly from these because neutron counting is random.
Reactor Startup and Kinetics: 1/M, Rod Worth, and Reactor Period
Nuclear Engineering Technology | Section: [Your Section] | Date: [Date]
Lab Members: [Names of all members present]
Purpose
To bring a PWR to criticality using subcritical multiplication and a 1/M plot to predict the critical rod position; to calculate the stable period, startup rate, doubling time, and power rise for small reactivity insertions; to measure the worth of a control-rod withdrawal by the period method; and to use graphs to compare 1/M estimates from two detectors and to find the largest reactivity a startup-rate limit allows.
Theory
In a subcritical core with a source, CR = S_eff/(1 − k), so (1 − k₁)CR₁ = (1 − k₂)CR₂ and 1/M = CR₀/CR falls to zero at criticality. Above critical, power rises as P = P₀e^(t/τ) with τ = (β − ρ)/(λρ), SUR = 26.06/τ, and T_d = τ ln 2.
Table A: Approach to Criticality (CR₀ = 100.0 cps, k₀ = 0.950) Undergraduate
| Bank (steps) | Counts (60 s) | CR (cps) | 1/M | k | Extrapolated critical position (steps) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 6000 | 100.0 | 1.0000 | 0.9500 | — |
| 40 | 6226 | 103.8 | 0.9637 | 0.9518 | 1102 (off scale) |
| 80 | 7939 | 132.3 | 0.7558 | 0.9622 | 225.4 |
| 120 | 15 700 | 261.7 | 0.3822 | 0.9809 | 160.9 |
| 140 | 31 819 | 530.3 | 0.1886 | 0.9906 | 159.5 |
| 150 | 58 400 | 973.3 | 0.1027 | 0.9949 | 162.0 |
| 160 | 212 702 | 3545.0 | 0.0282 | 0.9986 | 163.8 |
Sample calculation (150 steps): 1/M = 100.0/973.3 = 0.1027; k = 1 − 0.050 × 0.1027 = 0.9949; z_c = 150 + 10 × 0.1027/(0.1886 − 0.1027) = 162.0 steps. The count rate first failed to level off at 165 steps.
Table B: Period and Startup Rate (P₀ = 1 × 10⁻³ %) Undergraduate
| ρ (pcm) | τ (s) | SUR (dpm) | T_d (s) | Measured T_d (s) | P at 120 s (%) | Within 1 dpm? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 50 | 150.00 | 0.174 | 103.97 | 104.0 | 2.23 × 10⁻³ | yes |
| 100 | 68.75 | 0.379 | 47.65 | 47.7 | 5.73 × 10⁻³ | yes |
| 200 | 28.13 | 0.927 | 19.49 | 19.5 | 7.13 × 10⁻² | yes |
| 400 | 7.81 | 3.336 | 5.42 | 5.4 | reaches 1% at 54 s | no |
Table C: Rod Worth by the Period Method Undergraduate
| Insertion | Measured T_d (s) | τ = T_d/ln 2 (s) | ρ = β/(1 + λτ) (pcm) | Differential worth (pcm/step) | SUR (dpm) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bank D +10 steps past critical | 11.8 | 17.02 | 275 | 27.5 | 1.53 (above limit) |
Table D: 1/M Extrapolations from Two Detectors (logged startup, CR₀ = 100.0 cps) Upper undergraduateGraduate step
| Detector | Positions (steps) | 1/M first | 1/M second | Extrapolated critical position | Actual critical position | Conservative? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SR-1 | 100 → 120 | 0.5807 | 0.3821 | 158.5 | 164.3 | Yes |
| SR-1 | 130 → 140 | 0.2829 | 0.1886 | 160.0 | 164.3 | Yes |
| SR-1 | 140 → 145 | 0.1886 | 0.1444 | 161.3 | 164.3 | Yes |
| SR-2 | 100 → 120 | 0.7348 | 0.5531 | 180.9 | 164.3 | No |
| SR-2 | 130 → 140 | 0.4409 | 0.3173 | 165.7 | 164.3 | No |
| SR-2 | 140 → 145 | 0.3173 | 0.2523 | 164.4 | 164.3 | No |
z = z₂ + (z₂ − z₁)(1/M)₂/[(1/M)₁ − (1/M)₂]. Include a screenshot of the 1/M graph with your extrapolation drawn.
Graduate step: least-squares lines through three points give 161.3 steps (SR-1, 80–100–120) and 160.5 steps (SR-1, 130–140–145); for SR-2 they give 193.2 and 165.2 steps. For SR-1 the fits moved closer to the true 164.3 steps and stayed conservative; for SR-2 the fit through older points landed even further beyond it (193.2 against 180.9 steps).
Table E: Period Curve and Startup-Rate Limits (β = 0.0065, λ = 0.08 s⁻¹) Upper undergraduateGraduate step
| ρ (pcm) | ρ ($) | τ (s) | SUR (dpm) | Limit (dpm) | Largest ρ allowed (pcm) | Within limit? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 100 | 0.154 | 68.75 | 0.379 | 1 | 210.7 | Yes |
| 200 | 0.308 | 28.12 | 0.927 | 1 | 210.7 | Yes |
| 250 | 0.385 | 20.00 | 1.303 | 1 | 210.7 | No |
| 100 | 0.154 | 68.75 | 0.379 | 0.5 | 125.7 | Yes |
| 300 | 0.462 | 14.58 | 1.787 | 2 | 318.3 | Yes |
| 400 | 0.615 | 7.81 | 3.336 | 2 | 318.3 | No |
Largest ρ = β/(1 + λτ) with τ = 26.06/SUR limit.
Graduate step: the six-group inhour equation (ℓ = 2 × 10⁻⁵ s) gives τ = 54.88 s at 100 pcm, 17.31 s at 200 pcm and 3.05 s at 400 pcm, against 68.75, 28.12 and 7.81 s from one group. A 1 dpm limit (τ = 26.06 s) is reached at about 160 pcm, not 210.7 pcm.
Discussion
The count rate rose slowly at first and then steeply as k approached 1, from 100 cps with all rods in to 3545 cps at 160 steps. The first extrapolations were far too high (1102 and 225 steps), because the bank has little worth near the bottom of the core, so 1/M changed little for the first 40 steps. Once the bank reached the middle of the core, where its differential worth is greatest, the predictions converged on 162 to 164 steps, and criticality occurred at 165 steps. This is why procedures require a new 1/M point after every withdrawal and forbid large steps towards the predicted position.
Above critical, the measured doubling times matched τ ln 2 within the stopwatch resolution. The period shortened sharply as ρ increased: 100 pcm gave a gentle 0.38 dpm, while 400 pcm gave 3.3 dpm and would breach a 1 dpm startup-rate limit. As ρ approaches β = 650 pcm the period falls towards zero and the reactor would become prompt critical. The period method gave 275 pcm for 10 steps of bank D, or 27.5 pcm per step near mid-core. That withdrawal gave 1.53 dpm, so in a real startup it would have to be made in smaller steps.
The graphs showed why operators watch more than one detector. SR-1, far from the source, always predicted criticality before it happened (158.5 to 161.3 steps against 164.3), which is conservative. SR-2, close to the source, sees mostly source neutrons that are not multiplied, so its 1/M fell slowly and its early estimate (180.9 steps) was 17 steps beyond the real critical position. Both detectors converged as the rods neared critical. The period curve showed that the period falls steeply as ρ rises: a 1 dpm limit allows about 211 pcm, a 0.5 dpm limit only 126 pcm, and the curve drops toward zero at prompt criticality (650 pcm, $1.00).
The graduate steps showed the limits of the simple methods. Fitting three points instead of two did not make the SR-2 estimate conservative; only moving closer to criticality, or relying on the detector far from the source, did that. The six-group inhour equation gave periods 20–60% shorter than one group with λ = 0.08 s⁻¹, because the short-lived precursor groups respond faster at larger insertions. A startup that relied on the one-group curve would reach a 1 dpm startup rate at about 160 pcm, roughly 50 pcm earlier than predicted, so procedures and reactivity computers use the full six-group data.
Conclusion
Subcritical multiplication and the 1/M plot predicted the critical position to within about 1 step once the bank was near mid-core. The one-group period equation linked reactivity, period, startup rate, and doubling time, and a measured doubling time gave a rod worth of 275 pcm for 10 steps.
Practice Questions
Show all work and include units.